Someone stole the body!

[Jehanne]

Okay let's get real about sin here. Poking me in the eye would be a sin against me, a sin you did without God influencing you, God wouldn't do that. 
You are wanting to get into an area of God's rights as creator, this can be a complicated discussion that could take quite a while to complete, it would be better to do as a study than on a forum. God has providence over His entire creation and thus God is justified in anything He does that is within who He is. You need to understand this part of God's plan, it's to redeem all those who will accept His Son, Jesus Christ, for who He is and what He did for us. God is not in the business of tempting people to sin, that would be contrary to who He is.
 I was doing something in our discussion that I rarely ever do and that's to speculate a situation that would not ever happen and I should have let you know that to begin with, sorry.
 I'm not even sure how to try and go through a discussion like this in a forum format. I'll look up some theological explanations in one of my book to see if I can come up with something, could take some time. Just remember this, we understand from the scriptures that God can not sin and He will not tempt someone to sin, both would be contrary to who God is. I'm sure I've confused this even more and, shouldn't have started this discussion speculating an impossible situation, again I'm sorry, ask more questions and I'll try and get back to you Monday, have a good weekend.

It's interesting to think that God could appear before me and say, "I, God, command you to poke a baptist in the eye!"

And I could reply, "Nope. I'm an atheist. Not gonna do what you say, sorry."

And we would both be morally justified.

I'll bet a God who wasn't omnibenevolent would do that kind of thing, too. Just for fun.

God has a sense of divinely perfect humor.  After all, if God can order his Chosen People to murder innocent babies and children in cold blood, why not command poking a heretic in the eye?