A precognitive creator God is a special case, don't you think? It established all the initial conditions already knowing what all the outcomes would be. With the Biblical creation story, he would have known Eve and Adam as he made them would succumb to the temptation they were going to face and he made them exactly that way anyway rather than with the X% more resistancr to temptation that they needed to make the choice he wanted them to make. From that, it's obvious that the choice he wanted them to make was to fail his test, for which they were then punished for doing exactly what they were made to do. A precognitive creator is a mess for anyone who takes Bible stories literally. And he doesn't even have to be omnipotent, just powerful enough to set the initial conditions. If there's a precognitive creator who set the initial conditions, our choices are what he chose for us at the beginning, and free will is an illusion because of necessary pre-determinism.
I was asked about omnibenevolence. As a trait divorced from omnisicience and omnipotence, it's fine. Maybe an omnibenevolent God made the best universe it could manage. Maybe it sends the best people to class I heaven, the pretty good ones to class II, fairly scummy ones to class III, and the worst ones to the Phantom Zone or reincarnates them until they get it right. Combined with other omni-abilities, the Problem of Evil rears its ugly head, starting with the precognitive creator issue above.
I was asked about omnibenevolence. As a trait divorced from omnisicience and omnipotence, it's fine. Maybe an omnibenevolent God made the best universe it could manage. Maybe it sends the best people to class I heaven, the pretty good ones to class II, fairly scummy ones to class III, and the worst ones to the Phantom Zone or reincarnates them until they get it right. Combined with other omni-abilities, the Problem of Evil rears its ugly head, starting with the precognitive creator issue above.