Atheist arguments and the morality of God.

[John V]

Benevolent does not equal good. It would be benevolent for a judge to sentence a serial killer to eat a piece of chocolate cake and go on his way, but few people would think it's good of the judge to do that.

The problem I have with any of these analogies involving humans is that humans have a lot of qualities that God typically does not, and vice versa.

I didn't make an analogy between people and god there Robby, I made an illustration contrasting the definitions of good and benevolent.