It doesn't matter if you believe in Islam, Christianity, or Bacchism, Mystic. You could interchange whatever deity or spiritual phraseology you prefer, and you'd still be saying essentially the same thing. As an atheist, I'm no less enlightened about goodness and justice than you, I just prefer terminology that relates exclusively to the world of my fellow beings and takes into consideration the last 600 years of scientific progress, rather than obfuscate by using mythology or metaphors. Plain language is more effective.
He who loves God cannot endeavour that God should love him in return - Baruch Spinoza