Good Luck

[Lek]

I was just in the thread in which a member lived close to where the wildfires are burning in southern California and the member stated that she would ask for prayers, but that wouldn't do any good anyway. I am concerned and I did pray for all of them down there as I believe God listens to our prayers and does help people. What I read from atheists were wishes that things would be okay, with statements like "you're in my thoughts" and "good luck" and "take care of yourself" and so on. What does "being in your thoughts" do for anybody? Since these statements are totally worthless, why don't these people just skip the wasted words and make suggestions like "get some batteries since the power could go out" or "pack up and be ready to get out" or some practical help.

[The Valkyrie]

I was just in the thread in which a member lived close to where the wildfires are burning in southern California and the member stated that she would ask for prayers, but that wouldn't do any good anyway. I am concerned and I did pray for all of them down there as I believe God listens to our prayers and does help people. What I read from atheists were wishes that things would be okay, with statements like "you're in my thoughts" and "good luck" and "take care of yourself" and so on. What does "being in your thoughts" do for anybody? Since these statements are totally worthless, why don't these people just skip the wasted words and make suggestions like "get some batteries since the power could go out" or "pack up and be ready to get out" or some practical help.

They show that the person is thinking of them truly and honestly and not wasting their time praying to an imaginary being. The end result of prayer is, of course, that only the person praying actually feels better because he/she believes they've actually done something to help.

If I was there I'd actually be out trying to help, as opposed to sitting at home and praying.

The old saying holds true: "Two hands working achieve more than a thousand clasped in prayer".

[Foxaèr]

What does "being in your thoughts" do for anybody? Since these statements are totally worthless.

Sometimes it is nice to know that someone is thinking about you and your well-being. Personally, I do not care either way, but some people like to retain their humanistic natures despite their disbelief in any higher being.

[rexbeccarox]

I don't really say that to people, so I don't know the answer, but I do want to say thank you for starting a new thread and not hijacking mine

---

I was just in the thread in which a member lived close to where the wildfires are burning in southern California and the member stated that she would ask for prayers, but that wouldn't do any good anyway. I am concerned and I did pray for all of them down there as I believe God listens to our prayers and does help people. What I read from atheists were wishes that things would be okay, with statements like "you're in my thoughts" and "good luck" and "take care of yourself" and so on. What does "being in your thoughts" do for anybody? Since these statements are totally worthless, why don't these people just skip the wasted words and make suggestions like "get some batteries since the power could go out" or "pack up and be ready to get out" or some practical help.

They show that the person is thinking of them truly and honestly and not wasting their time praying to an imaginary being. The end result of prayer is, of course, that only the person praying actually feels better because he/she believes they've actually done something to help.

If I was there I'd actually be out trying to help, as opposed to sitting at home and praying.

The old saying holds true: "Two hands working achieve more than a thousand clasped in prayer".

That's really nice of you, but volunteers are being turned away, if you can believe it! Because one of the fires is in our big business district, a lot of people were evacuated yesterday, and can't go to work today or tomorrow, so they're volunteering at the shelters and stuff, and now there are so many, they're hindering progress.

[Minimalist]

God listens to our prayers and does help people.

Then why doesn't he put out the fucking fire?

[The Valkyrie]

I don't really say that to people, so I don't know the answer, but I do want to say thank you for starting a new thread and not hijacking mine

---

They show that the person is thinking of them truly and honestly and not wasting their time praying to an imaginary being. The end result of prayer is, of course, that only the person praying actually feels better because he/she believes they've actually done something to help.

If I was there I'd actually be out trying to help, as opposed to sitting at home and praying.

The old saying holds true: "Two hands working achieve more than a thousand clasped in prayer".

That's really nice of you, but volunteers are being turned away, if you can believe it! Because one of the fires is in our big business district, a lot of people were evacuated yesterday, and can't go to work today or tomorrow, so they're volunteering at the shelters and stuff, and now there are so many, they're hindering progress.

Yeah, often too many volunteers showing up just get in the way.

It's a good sign of the basic decency of many people, however.

[Napoléon]

What does "being in your thoughts" do for anybody?

The same amount as praying for somebody does.

Fuck all.


It's all well and good you have managed to convince yourself that praying makes a difference. But those of us in the real world realise it does absolutely jack shit. The sentiment is nice (just like saying "you're in our thoughts") but that's about it.

[Mystical]

I don't see any difference between someone saying 'you're in our thoughts', and 'you're in our prayers'. Except for the psychosis that's needed for pray-ers to believe that their thoughts will affect the outcome of the future.

[Ryantology]

What does "being in your thoughts" do for anybody?

It's a subtle difference, really. Offering that kind of platitude as above carries with it no false hope. Offering a prayer is like making a false promise on behalf of God, who is obviously lifting no divine fingers to help anybody.

[Lek]

I don't really say that to people, so I don't know the answer, but I do want to say thank you for starting a new thread and not hijacking mine

Actually, I think it's okay for people to say stuff like that and I also hope you and everyone there comes out of this well. I got set off because people will say "don't say you'll pray for me" as if it's an insult to do so, but people always say things like "you're in my thoughts", which they believe is as worthless as prayer, but that's acceptable.

---

God listens to our prayers and does help people.

Then why doesn't he put out the fucking fire?

He might save one person's home. My question to him is why he doesn't put out your mouth?