Music Is Forbbiden By Muhammad, But The Planets And Their Moons Make Music?

[ReptilianPeon]

Whether the sounds that our universe makes are actually music, that is to say, pleasing to the ear, is up for debate. But I think this is music in its own right. I like the 'music'/noise that Jupiter makes especially but all the planets make pleasing noises. All NASA has done is convert electromagnetic vibrations into sound Humans can hear using a computer. Is this Halal or Haram? And which is your favoruite planet or moon?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ToXaNUjNfS4

[Minimalist]

In the first place muhammad can go fuck himself...and in the second place.



There is no second place.

[Alex K]

Don't tell the Taliban or IS, or they'll build a death star to blow up the planets.

[WinterHold]

( 44 ) The seven heavens and the earth and whatever is in them exalt Him. And there is not a thing except that it exalts [Allah] by His praise, but you do not understand their [way of] exalting. Indeed, He is ever Forbearing and Forgiving.
http://quran.ksu.edu.sa/index.php?l=en#a...rans=en_sh

Now, we can finally hear and understand their way of exalting..
Music isn't forbidden by anyone, but Wahabbies/Salafies. Even Sunnies see music as "Halal".

[Lemonvariable72]

( 44 ) The seven heavens and the earth and whatever is in them exalt Him. And there is not a thing except that it exalts [Allah] by His praise, but you do not understand their [way of] exalting. Indeed, He is ever Forbearing and Forgiving.
http://quran.ksu.edu.sa/index.php?l=en#a...rans=en_sh

Now, we can finally hear and understand their way of exalting..

care to back that up or do we just have a bland assertion.

[ReptilianPeon]

( 44 ) The seven heavens and the earth and whatever is in them exalt Him. And there is not a thing except that it exalts [Allah] by His praise, but you do not understand their [way of] exalting. Indeed, He is ever Forbearing and Forgiving.
http://quran.ksu.edu.sa/index.php?l=en#a...rans=en_sh

Now, we can finally hear and understand their way of exalting..
Music isn't forbidden by anyone, but Wahabbies/Salafies. Even Sunnies see music as "Halal".

I would love to agree...except...the lady that first got me interested in the Quran said music was Haram (though interestingly never gave me a Quran verse or even Hadith to explain why; she stated only that music encourages Iblis or something like that). She was from Libya and didn't seem particularly extreme (to the extent of being Salafi/Wahhabi) - and I could tell because we exchanged many messages over a period of months - though the last time I spoke to her was years ago now. I never thought to ask her which branch she followed, and I now know Libya has a sizable Ibadi minority so it could be be that she wasn't even Sunni - like Libya's current (at the time of posting) head of state who is Ibadi himself - and she was influenced by Ibadi teachings (Ibadis have their own Hadith which are distinct from Sunni and Shia).

It's great that you've provided me with something. You know, now that I think about it, the people who are saying that music is Haram are only providing Hadith. I think there is a Quran verse - just one - which people like to interpret as saying music is bad but, if memory serves, the verse says nothing about music.

Some people, rather than say music is bad, say that only musical instruments are bad. Therefore, according to them, any sounds that animals, Humans, make are Halal. I think this is strange for the simple reason of Beatboxing. If you search "Beatboxing" you'll find the most amazing things. People can make noises exactly like musical instruments using only their own body. And I think Beatboxers would confuse the so-called scholars that determine what is Halal and what is Haram. Often I find these very uneducated people constantly dishing out Fatwas and people often don't have the knowledge or the time to read Hadith for themselves. Another reason why I ignore Hadith: I'm too lazy to read them all. And, even if I did, I'd then have to decide which I accept as authentic and which I don't. To be honest, I think many were written by people who I would call 'spin doctors'.

For example, did you know that Mermaids are Halal (to eat)? Anyone interested should do a quick search. Apparently there is a man from Saudi Arabia who issued a Fatwa and he said that he needs more evidence to determine whether or not Mermaids actually exist and that, if they do, they are permissible to eat.

[Mystic]

Shia scholars over all believe the word in hadiths (ghina) doesn't refer to all Music but Music associated with corruption. Some Shia scholars believe all Music is forbidden but they are a minority.

---

I'm not sure about what Sunni scholars say. Perhaps Rayaan will educate us on that.

[Minimalist]

Music is far superior to any kind of religious bullshit.

"Music has charms to soothe a savage breast,"

--William Congreve

While religion is ideal for savage breasts.

[WinterHold]

( 44 ) The seven heavens and the earth and whatever is in them exalt Him. And there is not a thing except that it exalts [Allah] by His praise, but you do not understand their [way of] exalting. Indeed, He is ever Forbearing and Forgiving.
http://quran.ksu.edu.sa/index.php?l=en#a...rans=en_sh

Now, we can finally hear and understand their way of exalting..
Music isn't forbidden by anyone, but Wahabbies/Salafies. Even Sunnies see music as "Halal".

I would love to agree...except...the lady that first got me interested in the Quran said music was Haram (though interestingly never gave me a Quran verse or even Hadith to explain why; she stated only that music encourages Iblis or something like that). She was from Libya and didn't seem particularly extreme (to the extent of being Salafi/Wahhabi) - and I could tell because we exchanged many messages over a period of months - though the last time I spoke to her was years ago now. I never thought to ask her which branch she followed, and I now know Libya has a sizable Ibadi minority so it could be be that she wasn't even Sunni - like Libya's current (at the time of posting) head of state who is Ibadi himself - and she was influenced by Ibadi teachings (Ibadis have their own Hadith which are distinct from Sunni and Shia).

It's great that you've provided me with something. You know, now that I think about it, the people who are saying that music is Haram are only providing Hadith. I think there is a Quran verse - just one - which people like to interpret as saying music is bad but, if memory serves, the verse says nothing about music.

Some people, rather than say music is bad, say that only musical instruments are bad. Therefore, according to them, any sounds that animals, Humans, make are Halal. I think this is strange for the simple reason of Beatboxing. If you search "Beatboxing" you'll find the most amazing things. People can make noises exactly like musical instruments using only their own body. And I think Beatboxers would confuse the so-called scholars that determine what is Halal and what is Haram. Often I find these very uneducated people constantly dishing out Fatwas and people often don't have the knowledge or the time to read Hadith for themselves. Another reason why I ignore Hadith: I'm too lazy to read them all. And, even if I did, I'd then have to decide which I accept as authentic and which I don't. To be honest, I think many were written by people who I would call 'spin doctors'.

For example, did you know that Mermaids are Halal (to eat)? Anyone interested should do a quick search. Apparently there is a man from Saudi Arabia who issued a Fatwa and he said that he needs more evidence to determine whether or not Mermaids actually exist and that, if they do, they are permissible to eat.

If memory doesn't betray me, it's the verse that starts with "ومن الناس من يشري لهو الحديث...". Which doesn't refer to music at all ; all of the fatwas are backed by Hadith.

About the mermaids..here's the fatwa in Arabic :





The "sheikh" says : the human of the sea "half fish half human" exists..he says it's halal to eat it........Thank you for this information, MrNoMorePropaganda, I never saw this video before

[WinterHold]

Though...OMG animal planet ?? I mean could this be real ? what do you think MNMP ?