Old forum member Shell_B has released a short horror story online as part of a competition. Download for free in ebook, Kindle, or PDF format!
Our server costs $25 per month to run. Please consider donating to help keep the site running. Help us gain new members by following us on Twitter and liking our page on Facebook!
 
Current time: 3rd July 2015, 09:17

Thread Rating:
  • 0 Vote(s) - 0 Average
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
A question regarding proof
#1
A question regarding proof
I had a dream about a pony last night.

Can my pony dream be objectively proven?
Reply
#2
RE: A question regarding proof
I don't know, can it, provide your evidence.
“I find something repulsive about the idea of vicarious redemption. I would not throw my numberless sins onto a scapegoat and expect them to pass from me" - Christopher Hitchens.


Reply
#3
RE: A question regarding proof
If all we have to go by is your word, no.
"It could be a miracle. It could be bullshit. The one thing we do know for sure is that it's a goddamn goldmine." - Frank, from It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia
Reply
#4
RE: A question regarding proof
What an odd question. Of course you can't prove you had a dream. But by the same token, if you told me you had a dream about a pony, I'd be inclined to believe you, because I wouldn't see the point in lying about it. You could be lying, and you'd probably get away with it if you were.
Reply
#5
RE: A question regarding proof
I had a dream that I was a pony in someone else's dream. I was in your dream, OP. Prove I wasn't.
Reply
#6
RE: A question regarding proof
(7th September 2011, 19:32)Rhythm Wrote: I don't know, can it, provide your evidence.

No evidence exists. I cannot prove it and neither can you or anyone else.
(7th September 2011, 19:35)FaithNoMore Wrote: If all we have to go by is your word, no.

That's all we have, so yes, the correct answer is no.
Reply
#7
RE: A question regarding proof
No evidence exists, or you personally have no evidence?
“I find something repulsive about the idea of vicarious redemption. I would not throw my numberless sins onto a scapegoat and expect them to pass from me" - Christopher Hitchens.


Reply
#8
RE: A question regarding proof
(7th September 2011, 19:48)ElDinero Wrote: What an odd question.

Not at all. Let's walk it out.

Quote:Of course you can't prove you had a dream.

Exactly.

Quote:But by the same token, if you told me you had a dream about a pony, I'd be inclined to believe you,

Why on earth would you believe something for which there was no evidence? That's crazy.

Quote:because I wouldn't see the point in lying about it. You could be lying, and you'd probably get away with it if you were.

There is no proof whatsoever for my dream pony, so of course I am lying. How could it be otherwise? There is simply no credible evidence for the existence of a dream pony, so anyone who claims to have had the experience is lying or delusional.
(7th September 2011, 19:54)Rhythm Wrote: No evidence exists, or you personally have no evidence?

No objective evidence exists.
Reply
#9
RE: A question regarding proof
Sounds like a claim of absolute certainty. It's probably more appropriate to say that you have no such evidence, and are currently at a loss as to how to provide such evidence.
That being said, I've had dreams, many people report dreams. Ponies don't sound too far fetched do they. I definitely don't have any evidence to the contrary. There doesn't seem to be anything in this statement that is so far fetched as to require verification unless one needed to be technical, so I'd give you your pony dream. (I wouldn't raise my hand and swear that you had a pony dream on my life, but I'd swear that you claimed to have had a pony dream on my life)

PS: I don't think any of this means what you think it means, or supports some argument that you're going to attempt to make anyway.
“I find something repulsive about the idea of vicarious redemption. I would not throw my numberless sins onto a scapegoat and expect them to pass from me" - Christopher Hitchens.


Reply
#10
RE: A question regarding proof
Oh, I see, you were trying to trick me. Obviously not the same thing, mostly because whether or not you dreamed about a pony doesn't matter. Rather than say I'd believe you, it would be better to say 'I would think nothing of your claim'. If you made a claim that you dreamed about a pony and it became real, that would require further testing.
Reply


Possibly Related Threads...
Thread Author Replies Views Last Post
  The Proof! rtfguy 50 2003 2nd October 2014, 17:01
Last Post: TaraJo
  Proof of the soul? JesusLover1 50 2402 6th March 2014, 12:23
Last Post: pocaracas
  Why atheism always has a burden of proof Vincenzo "Vinny" G. 358 50794 31st October 2013, 21:40
Last Post: Stimbo
Wink Proof that God(s) can not exist. way12go 19 2864 18th August 2013, 22:22
Last Post: bennyboy
  Burden of Proof Mark 13:13 213 24304 12th January 2013, 20:38
Last Post: Stimbo
  Finally, proof there is no god! Tempus 6 2280 15th August 2012, 00:17
Last Post: Minimalist
  I have proof of God, from God Himself. MuslimBrother 13 3398 30th May 2012, 16:17
Last Post: whateverist
  Why do Athiests require 'proof' that God exists? JesusLover 220 32480 16th May 2012, 13:18
Last Post: Chaostheosis
  Proof of existence of God jain.rahul 21 4532 15th May 2012, 19:05
Last Post: Jörmungandr
  The Burden of Proof Atheistfreethinker 45 7728 24th August 2011, 19:10
Last Post: Cthulhu Dreaming



Users browsing this thread: 1 Guest(s)