Valid Arguments for God (soundness disputed)
March 25, 2017 at 9:44 am
(This post was last modified: March 25, 2017 at 9:45 am by Mystic.)
I've posted many arguments over the years that are valid, what is disputed is not the validity of argument.
These are the lists of premises I've seen disputed (not by everyone, but my many).
1. Morality cannot be that it's morally good to torture a baby for eternity in all possible worlds.
If you guys recall this was the premise that people disputed to disprove an argument showing morality to be eternal.
2. We have exact value to who we are.
This seems to be the latest debate, it seems people are not willing to acknowledge that we know this to be true. I've tried to show signs of it being true, from how we love one another, I was about to talk about animals and humans as well.... but this seems to be disputed.
3. Who we are and judgment is interlinked so much so we required an exact judgment of who we are to be who we are.
4. Objective morality exists.
5. Ranks pertain to real living reality and is not merely conceptual.
6. We have a perpetual identity that makes us linked to who we are as babies till now, no matter what we choose to be or become.
7. We have a basis to all perception of greatness, morality, beauty (I've heard many say we don't, rather all these are just human constructs).
8. We inherit our actions.
There are probably much more, but these are the ones I remember on top of my head.
These are the lists of premises I've seen disputed (not by everyone, but my many).
1. Morality cannot be that it's morally good to torture a baby for eternity in all possible worlds.
If you guys recall this was the premise that people disputed to disprove an argument showing morality to be eternal.
2. We have exact value to who we are.
This seems to be the latest debate, it seems people are not willing to acknowledge that we know this to be true. I've tried to show signs of it being true, from how we love one another, I was about to talk about animals and humans as well.... but this seems to be disputed.
3. Who we are and judgment is interlinked so much so we required an exact judgment of who we are to be who we are.
4. Objective morality exists.
5. Ranks pertain to real living reality and is not merely conceptual.
6. We have a perpetual identity that makes us linked to who we are as babies till now, no matter what we choose to be or become.
7. We have a basis to all perception of greatness, morality, beauty (I've heard many say we don't, rather all these are just human constructs).
8. We inherit our actions.
There are probably much more, but these are the ones I remember on top of my head.
