I would say there is a problem with hadiths. If the person has so much faith in hadiths, surely he would believe in the miracles of the Prophet attributed to him in those. But he doesn't.
Quran teaches the opposite. It showed people were insulting the Prophet, but that he should bear patience on what they say. It didn't say go kill them for that.
I agree there is a problem with Islam and how the Prophet is portrayed and the teachings attributed to him, but, to me, unless you can prove a certain evil through Quran, it should not be taken as a fact. Having a reliable chain means nothing when Ilmel Rijaal is not science but a subjective opinion of people who had motives of their own and didn't know and had no way of knowing who is truly truthful and who is liar.
Quran teaches the opposite. It showed people were insulting the Prophet, but that he should bear patience on what they say. It didn't say go kill them for that.
I agree there is a problem with Islam and how the Prophet is portrayed and the teachings attributed to him, but, to me, unless you can prove a certain evil through Quran, it should not be taken as a fact. Having a reliable chain means nothing when Ilmel Rijaal is not science but a subjective opinion of people who had motives of their own and didn't know and had no way of knowing who is truly truthful and who is liar.
