(September 16, 2021 at 5:00 pm)Angrboda Wrote: All you've shown is that, in addition to making vapid semantic arguments, you are tone-deaf to the equivocation required to posit that Hawking-Hartle requires a beginning. Now, unless you've got an argument that isn't fallacious, I'll consider the matter closed and your objections refuted.
Major Premise: A bishop can only move diagonally.
Minor Premise: The Pope is the bishop of Rome.
Conclusion: Therefore, the Pope can only move diagonally.