(March 2, 2010 at 3:24 pm)Eilonnwy Wrote: Adrian, I'm not the one claiming that a non-material being interacts with the material world.You said "if the non-material being is said to interact with the material world, we have something to talk about". My point was that if the being is defined as non-material, then the only thing you have to talk about is the invalidity of either the description "non-material" or the being's ability to interact with the material world.
In other words, asking for evidence of such a being (if described as immaterial) is as ridiculous as asking for evidence of beings from the 4th dimension.