(August 18, 2009 at 7:06 am)northumbrian66 Wrote: However, I would think that any true Athiest would agree with the sentiment.
Any true atheist? So you've gotta then define 'true atheist'. Because doesn't 'any true atheist would agree'= 'no true athiest would disagree'? In which case, since atheists are just those who don't believe in God, unless you can define preciesly what a 'true atheist' is (and, for the record - I don't see how you can!), aren't you, perhaps, implicity comitting the No True Scotsman fallacy?
EvF