(May 28, 2013 at 5:18 pm)Statler Waldorf Wrote: I think it helps if you identify what fallacy you think has been committed by the poster. Although I do not understand the entire context of that quote, I do not see a very obvious fallacy there.
My bad, I thought the game was to ID the fallacy, but it was probably not clear out of context.
It's an ad hom, essentially he's arguing that atheist critiques of his posts are invalid because they're coming from atheists and we're only saying what we're programmed to say. He doesn't address the substance of the criticisms at all and doesn't see how easily his complaint is reversed.