(June 7, 2016 at 2:47 pm)Mister Agenda Wrote:ChadWooters Wrote:IMHO, all a Christian believer can really say is that skeptics have not adequately shown that a better world than ours was possible. Skeptics have only their incredulity. The bible records many instances where people of faith expressed the same doubts about Divine Justice. Job comes to mind. So we, as believers, shouldn’t fool ourselves into thinking that we have any proof that vindicates God. In the end, we really only have plausible excuses and our trust in His Lordship. For the faithful, the mere possibility of a plausible excuse is sufficient to overcome their own incredulity.
That said, the skeptic cannot say that Christian’s offer no plausible excuses. There are many, but even still, Christian vindications of Benevolent Providence remain tentative at best. The problem of evil is and emotional, not logical, rejection of the Christian God**.
1. A tri-Omni entity who can't do better than this world is a contradiction in terms.
2. Lots of excuses, none of them plausible.
Traditionally, the excuses mostly consist of temporarily forgetting that god is supposed to be omnipotent, or that that he is supposed to be omniscient, or that he's supposed to be omnibenevolent. I say temporarily because the people who give up god's benevolence for the sake of argument will then turn around and worship him for his goodness.
So I like to say that the art of defending against the problem of evil consists largely of not realizing what you have given up. To be consistent, you have to give up omnipotence, omniscience, or omnibenevolence; but, to continue worshiping a tri-omni god, you have to not realize that you gave it up.
Not all responses to the PoE are of this equivocal nature. Some people really don't believe god is all that benevolent. Some don't think he knows the future. (He had to guess what would make the Hebrews happy. When having them cut off the ends of their dicks didn't work, he went on to try other things.) Some really don't think god is all that smart.
But these people, people who actually give up omnipotence, omniscience, or omnibenevolence (as opposed to just making a feint in that direction and then reverting to their prior beliefs) don't have any reason to argue against the PoE. They already know that a tri-omni god can't coexist with evil, which is why their gods aren't tri-omni.