My first problem is with the first premise. What reason is there to believe that it is true? And what is a "moral conscience" as opposed to just a "conscience"? Why would one be obligated to follow one's conscience? And does everyone have such a thing (a conscience) at all?
Frankly, I am suspicious that the first premise is false, even if it is meaningful, which isn't clear either.
I have problems with pretty much every other premise as well, but this should be enough to give the idea that I am unimpressed.
Frankly, I am suspicious that the first premise is false, even if it is meaningful, which isn't clear either.
I have problems with pretty much every other premise as well, but this should be enough to give the idea that I am unimpressed.
"A wise man ... proportions his belief to the evidence."
— David Hume, An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding, Section X, Part I.
