Argument from Conscience

[Kingpin]

OK, thanks for your answer

I'm afraid I can't make any sense of it however. But I appreciate you trying.

If we're all immoral, what is the point of morality? This sounds exactly like the thing I hate most about Christianity, the idea that we are all somehow "wrong". That we are doomed to be not good enough, no matter what we do. It's a disgusting idea. This is breaking your leg and selling you a crutch.

If God in person contradicts what other people have told you are god's commandments, you'd pick what people have told you, which is now obviously actually not from God at all?

Let me make a bold statement and see if you agree:

You think rape is immoral regardless of whether God says it is or not.

Yes.  Because I would never want that to happen to me nor would I want to intentionally harm someone else.