A question

[Athene]

---

Since you theists believe humans are nothing but sinners here is a logical question. 

Your father walks into your room and he glaring at you. You sit there doing nothing minding your own 
business he then walks over to you and beats the ever loving shit out of you and asks that you pray to him for forgiveness 
because your great great great grandfather stole a apple.  After he finishes beating you and he says he loves you 
the next time he beats you would you A. deny the punishment B. accept the punishment.

---

You do understand that your analogy does not reflect what is going on in Christianity. To fix your analogy you would be the apple thief who does not/will not stop stealing apples

You "forgot" the part where dear old Dad has a microchip implanted in his brain at birth that programs his son to steal apples. 

You just refuse to acknowledge that crucial element of the story, don't you?