Mock dialogue of the Theist/Atheist discussion here.

[Mystic]

Then beyond your three dialogs, we really have nothing to discuss. The unseen and the nonexistent are much the same.

I think we can disagree, but can have discussion whether or not religion is necessarily illogical or irrational. If we believe in the unseen absolute (God), we should believe in the unseen path to Him? Do you agree on that much? So suppose there was an unseen path, suppose there was..........sort of dialogue...is that useless to?

I think Islam becomes very rational if you believe in God. I think believing in God but no unseen path to traverse on is useless belief. 

If you however believe in the unseen path, is not a connection to it possible? What would would those who whole path is nothing but that path that leads to God, what role would they play in guiding others to that path?

We can have dialogue.

If all comes down to prove the unseen or your religion is irrational...then yes, we can't have dialogue.