IATIA,
Bolding mine.
I see what you did there. Well played.
I have already responded to this line of thinking. I'll reiterate. We already have a past. Knowing what we did yesterday does not change the free nature of our will in choosing what we did yesterday. We will think thoughts and make choices today, of our own free will. Tomorrow we will know what those thoughts and choices were. That knowledge will not suddenly make our thoughts and choices from today the only possible choices we could have made. Time is irrelevant.
Regards,
Shadow_Man
IATIA Wrote:We would be nothing but shadows playing out what has already happened.
Bolding mine.
I see what you did there. Well played.
IATIA Wrote:Your god and time travel run in the same boat. If the future exists, then we are the past and have already
made the choices. We would be nothing but shadows playing out what has already happened.
I have already responded to this line of thinking. I'll reiterate. We already have a past. Knowing what we did yesterday does not change the free nature of our will in choosing what we did yesterday. We will think thoughts and make choices today, of our own free will. Tomorrow we will know what those thoughts and choices were. That knowledge will not suddenly make our thoughts and choices from today the only possible choices we could have made. Time is irrelevant.
Regards,
Shadow_Man