Most overrated game?

[Aroura]

For me, Skyrim.

Yeah, it's big and flashy.  But FUCK, scaling mobs make the game feel so pointless.  I could literally max out my character by going back to the same areas over and over and over again, and fighting the harder and harder enemies until I had my crystal armor.  There's no sense that the world is anything but a slow reveal of new armor sets.

I have to agree.  It was a step backwards from prior games like Morrowind and Oblivion.  It was gorgeous to look at, but lacked the sandboxy creativity of the previous games.