(May 12, 2016 at 9:48 am)robvalue Wrote: Yes, that is a big problem. If you start saying logic doesn't apply to god, you've just thrown away all your tools. It's the ultimate argument from ignorance.
You can forget the stupid Kalam argument for a start.
He's all for inductive logic when he thinks it supports him. When he's against logic is when we think it supports us and he can't come up with a logical defeater for our arguments. At that point, logic becomes a kind of chicanery that other people shouldn't be allowed to use.
-
@ RoadRunner: This is a perfect example to answer your question "Why?" in post 708.
