If I have to relearn everything, then it is not I who am living the next life which makes the entire proposition nonsensical other than to say I am simply rewinding the tape and doing it again. Your invocation of different circumstance suggests we are not simply rewinding the tape so I must press, do I carry forward my knowledge and experience, or don't I?
It's not my intent to be a burr in the saddle, but I think the distinction is crucial to the thought experiment.
It's not my intent to be a burr in the saddle, but I think the distinction is crucial to the thought experiment.