(June 3, 2016 at 2:32 pm)YahwehIsTheWay Born Again Wrote: 1. You think Islam is a "race"
Not really. There are a lot of ignorant people who equate Muslims with Arabs, but this happens on both sides anyway.
Quote:2. You think criticism of Islam is "bigotry"
Nope, but I do think the amount of bigotry and prejudice I've noticed against Muslim people is unjustified.
Quote:3. You think religion is never, ever, ever to blame for sectarian violence
Well, if you think religion is the main reason for sectarian violence or extremism to the exclusion of all other factors, then you're ignorant.
Quote:4. When someone is attacked for blasphemy, you suggest the victim should have "been more sensitive".
Never suggested that.
Quote:5. You react to any criticism of Islam, no matter how precise the language is to theocracy or extremism, as "painting all Muslims with a broad brush"
I look at the argument supposedly being present against Islam. If instead it ends up being more to enable bigotry against Muslim people because they happen to be Muslims rather than Christians or atheists, then yeah, I'm going to have a problem with it.
Quote:6. You go "Godwin" on any critics of Islam
Nope. But if people show bigotry against Muslim people themselves, then that obviously should be seen just as bad as antisemitism.
Quote:7. You immediately lump all critics of Islam in with the neo-cons.
Nope.
Quote:8. You believe in free speech "but..."
People can be bigoted bigot all they like. But I have a right to free speech as well, right? Or is there a but here somewhere?
Quote:9. You suggest the problem with Islamic extremism is "extremism", not Islam.
Addressed above. Not reasonable to look at these things in such a narrow-minded way. Plus, the majority of Muslims are not even extremists.
Quote:10. You're a cultural and moral relativist.
Nope. But I advocate at least basic respect and dignity for Muslims, Christians, Jews, and atheists. Their adherence to a certain major religion should not be a reason to be bitter towards them just because you're ignorant about the causes of violence and extremism. And frankly, bigotry and prejudice against Muslim people specifically (rather than just rage directed towards those who actually are terrorists) is what I notice a lot in real life, in the media, and on a few occasions, here as well.
