(June 16, 2016 at 12:23 pm)Rhythm Wrote:NoRoadRunner79 Wrote:[quote=For instance in such discussions; I am 99% sure,b-mine
Let me stop you right here..because it's important. Is that an adequate description of your god's omniscience?
Quote:The full quote is "For instance in such discussions; I am 99% sure, that someone is going to argue, that knowing the choice one is going to make, violates free will."Quote:that someone is going to argue, that knowing the choice one is going to make, violates free will.Sure would.
Are you saying I should be 100% certain?
Quote:Why not... if I can relatively accurately predict the choice you are going to make, then did you really have a choice?Quote:Does this mean, that they only had 1% free will to do so?Nope.
What about the scenario I asked about (care to answer those questions)?
Are our choices based on something from within ourselves? Is it based on reason and experience? Are we responsible for our choices? It seems to me, that in being over zealous on the "free" part of the equation, that you are eliminating the "will" part of it.