(September 6, 2016 at 2:06 pm)Alasdair Ham Wrote: Okay I'll help you out. Or try to.
Okay here we go:
Premise 1 by Hammy Wrote:Subjectivity is ontologically objectively existent.
You accept this premise. So... this is the thing... we have subjective moral values. You accept that we have ontologically objectively existent subjectivity. Our subjective moral values reside within our subjectivity ontologically objectively speaking.
ETA: I did leave the word out. It was implicit. As a friend would say.
Just to note... I think that you may be confusing my posts with Julia. I did reply to a post, in reference to her, because I believe there was some confusion.
I didn't read it as implicit. You didn't mention morality until premise 2, in which if I went back, I may have implied it, but I took it to mean what it said, without going back.
I could agree with what it says (i think).... I wouldn't agree morality is subjective in nature (if that is what you are saying).
