On Logic and Alternate Universes

[FallentoReason]

No. I've never done that.

-guess it's time to start quoting you again.

It doesn't matter what they mean in our 3-d universe, because I'm interested in the incomprehensible meaning that another universe with another set of logical rules would have, and if that meaning can actually be said to be "logical", which in the OP I have shown it is.

What haven't you said, again....and of course you tried so hard to ditch the many, many times you said it in the last thread only to fuck up again, huh.  

 I don't care about identity.

Clearly, and that's the problem.

I care about the class of thing that they are.

Then call goblygoop axiomish, since it's the class of thing that concerns you...or just, idk.."a set of axioms"?  It's not logical, that's reserved for another set of axioms, logical ones.  In addition to identity, you don't care about equivocation or false equivalencies... yet again, the problem.  If you want these things to be different, if you must insist that they are different, then allow them to be different, ffs.

Your entire argument is uninteresting, because it's a triviality of the english language. Look I can play your game too:

Bicycles are bicycly
oranges are orangy
toast is toasty

They mean absolutely nothing. 

The discussion at hand just so happens to have a noun which is also an adjective. Your use of it, however, is completely uninteresting. And you've shown that already with other examples such as 'bobly' and 'fredly'. Completely void of any meaning, because yes, we already *know* bob = bob, and to be bobly is to be bob. Here's the kicker - 'logical' *is not* the same uselessness as the others. Look it up in the dictionary. Oh wait, I've done that for you and you've ignored it ever since coming to this thread. 'Logical' isn't reserved for a description of our logic. That's the entirety of your game that you're playing, and it's pointless. Our logic happens to be logical because it's a set of axioms. End of. Any other such set will also be logical because any other such set will count as being the thing which we, here on this universe, with the english language, call 'logic'. Anything outside of this - uninteresting uses of words and letters to convey absolutely nothing.