(November 6, 2016 at 1:31 pm)Alasdair Ham Wrote: I told you enough times it doesn't fucking matter what universe it is and I've given my reasons. A=A is absolute in all hypotheticals. Address that.
Jesus fuck, Ham, you're so stubbornly arguing a point upon which there is no disagreement that you're missing Rhythm's point, and the point of the OP, entirely.
If your point is that we can't entertain absurdities, well, you're just wrong about that. It's a goddamned thought experiment, not an existential claim.