I agree with you. Simply because even if the law of identity is only true to us as we observe the world with our animal brains, or whatever, we can't really escape our own perceptions, so it's meaningless to wonder what might lie beyond them.
But you are making a mistake when you go ahead and talk about what an universe without any conscious intelligence to observe it would be like. That's irrational in and of itself. It wouldn't exist simply because existence is a concept. Everything is. Qualia is absolute and universal. Without it you have nothing. Literally.
But you are making a mistake when you go ahead and talk about what an universe without any conscious intelligence to observe it would be like. That's irrational in and of itself. It wouldn't exist simply because existence is a concept. Everything is. Qualia is absolute and universal. Without it you have nothing. Literally.
