I know it's bad to revive threads, but I feel this was one of the better discussions.
I want to say we can prove the thesis by contradiction:
It's absurd to say false judgement can define who we are and it's obvious we can falsely estimate ourselves and that our value cannot be just chaotically assigned to what we desire, yet it was obvious that value is a thing given by perception.
This shows 1. We are defined by value giver that is right in it's judgement. 2. That we are created in a way that actions and value are interlinked and value either negatively or positively happens with our actions.
I would define actions as series of states that forms a summary of usually a goal or various goals in mind. For example I biked to school, is a series of me biking and the goal is to get to school through biking (and it may have other intentions like exercise, losing weight).
Actions being a series of states means the goal or goals and the spirit while doing it, the life force behind it, get's inherited to who we are and the value we are.
To say our actions are not and we simply decide what our value is by those actions and assign it, has been proven wrong, as we can have absurd morals like Hitler and think we are some sort of hero.
I want to say we can prove the thesis by contradiction:
It's absurd to say false judgement can define who we are and it's obvious we can falsely estimate ourselves and that our value cannot be just chaotically assigned to what we desire, yet it was obvious that value is a thing given by perception.
This shows 1. We are defined by value giver that is right in it's judgement. 2. That we are created in a way that actions and value are interlinked and value either negatively or positively happens with our actions.
I would define actions as series of states that forms a summary of usually a goal or various goals in mind. For example I biked to school, is a series of me biking and the goal is to get to school through biking (and it may have other intentions like exercise, losing weight).
Actions being a series of states means the goal or goals and the spirit while doing it, the life force behind it, get's inherited to who we are and the value we are.
To say our actions are not and we simply decide what our value is by those actions and assign it, has been proven wrong, as we can have absurd morals like Hitler and think we are some sort of hero.
