(June 26, 2017 at 9:31 pm)Astonished Wrote: Okay, all you agnostics here, if you want my two cents...tell me, what is it you're still unsure about that you are willing to say you haven't got enough information or knowledge to make a probabilistic determination about whatever it is you are suspending judgment about?
It's the difference between judgement and knowledge. In my judgement, there are no gods. To my knowledge, I've seen no evidence.
Don't get me wrong, I can write off many of them by virtue of their claimed characteristics. I do that with the Abrahamic god, based on claimed qualities. Indeed, I write off most all of them because I think magic is horseshit, and they all seem to rely upon magic to work.
But do I know? No, I don't. What might seem to me to be magic might be another way of the Universe operating, and some religion somewhere might have something I don't know about.
In short, agnostic atheist is not my claim about the Universe, but my claim about myself.
