Testimony is Evidence

[Astonished]

How 'bout answering the question I put to you, in bold and italicized? All you've done so far is yet more spinning for the strengths of testimony in the face of physical evidence to the contrary.

As I said, I think it is an odd position which I have only seen in this extreme view from atheist groups. So I wanted to look at the reasons for it and if it is justified. I wanted to discuss it.  From the other thread, which I did not intend for debate, others seemed to want to discuss it, and criticized me for not discussing it there, even though I told them to make a thread.  Now, it seems that most don't want to discuss it, and are questioning me for doing so.  

Why is my reason important to you?   Do you want me to just accept your claims without reasoning or evidence?  Can I not be skeptical?

Your reason is important because you're still clinging to this even though you've been proven wrong. This is like trying to fight your way through us to pull the switch on the electric chair to execute someone you still think is guilty even after we've proved they're not, you think that's not going to bother us and make us wonder what the hell is wrong with you that's making you still do this? And you claiming we've got no reasoning or evidence is you projecting your failures onto us, STOP IT, for fuck's sake, you're not fooling anyone and just revealing your own idiocy. You're the exact opposite of skeptical and we've proven that. Admit you're dead fucking wrong on at least one of these counts or just stop, this is fucking ridiculous.