RE: God Yahweh Allah was a volcano.
August 5, 2011 at 10:46 pm
(This post was last modified: August 5, 2011 at 10:59 pm by theVOID.)
(August 5, 2011 at 1:08 pm)Hannah Wrote:
It would be far more reasonable to assume this narrative influenced the people's superstitions not by making them believe their god was a volcano, rather they attributed volcanic activity, earthquakes and many other things to the wrath of a God. None of this is supportive of the Idea that YHWH was a volcano.
Then again, nobody has actually found these cities, are there any extra-biblical sources for their existence? It is entirely likely that while some people may have found an area of volcanic activity where an earthquake once happened saying that two cities from a religious text once existed here and since we can't find them they must have fell down an abyss is bit ridiculous. Just how well are their locations described in the bible?
(August 5, 2011 at 7:23 pm)Hannah Wrote: I am recent Christian apostate who left Christianity due to a sinking feeling about a volcano.
And now you're looking for evidence to demonstrate a "sinking feeling"? Nothing necessarily wrong with that, just be aware of the biases you can fall prey to with this approach, especially when your feeling lead you to make a substantial world change.
Quote:I have a hunch the entire God-feeling can be put down to volcanoes and, being a free thinking truth seeker, I want to see if the evidence points to this.
You could falsify this rather easily if you're interested, for instance if you find a culture with a God who is clearly not a volcano or multiple gods who are clearly representative of something else. I can name about a dozen from the Maori culture; Ranginui was the "sky father", Tāne-mahuta was the "god of the forests and birds", Tangaroa was the "god of the sea", Rongo the "God of peace and agriculture", Haumia-tiketike the "God of wild foods", Rehua the Star and guidance, Punga the "god of ugly creatures" Etc...
Compared to the very few which could be in any way attributed to a volcano; Papatūānuku the "Earth mother", Ruaumoko the "source of earthquakes" and Tāwhirimātea the "god of weather"
This soundly disproves the notion that the "entire God-feeling" can be put down to volcanoes. With evidence now presented in strict contradiction to this notion will you now, being a truth seeker, drop that proposition?
.