(November 28, 2017 at 12:50 pm)Hammy Wrote: You don't seem to even understand how logic works. Logic actually has to make sense and follow logically, logic doesn't just have to seem smart and result in a conclusion you like the sound of. I am correct because the argument indeed does NOT show that the uncaused cause must be God.
Two things:
1) Neither you or anyone else on AF has revealed any actual flaw in the logic of the 5W, despite repeated and unsupported assertions that it has been debunked. Not once and I've been here for nearly 4 years.
2) It doesn't matter that the prime mover isn't called out definitatively as the Christian God. This is one attribute among many that is traditionally associated with the God of Classical theism that is available to natural reason. Special revelation is necessary to make that relationship explicit although as I have said many times further logical demonstrations show that the attributes of prime mover, necessary being, etc. are unified in a single being that is absolutely simple.
