Ybe an atheist

[robvalue]

RV: ...putting the microscope on the wrong side...

 YB:  Agreed, there are 2 sides. Either (A) or (not A).  Inspection is about if A side is reasonable or not.

 RV: We're talking about...
 YB: A or not A

 RV: A simple example from your side could destroy my entire case.
 Ybe: Your case being, A side is reasonable? (Just focusing here).
 
RV: 1) Incoherent: lacking any useful meaning, or so vague as to provide no substance.

This is, of course, subjective. I'm not claiming to be perfect. I'm responding to reality on its own terms, and the claims I'm given to the best of my ability. I'd be very interested in something actually real here, so it's in my interest to try and fish out anything that could lead to something. If I can't understand something, I can't evaluate it. That's a fact I just can't get around. I always encourage people to explain (as you're doing) and allow them to get around my barriers if they wish.

YB: I will have to take this  a little at a time. Re your above. Sorry, a few terms I need defined to understand and evaluate.
 vague -
 substance -
 subjective -
 perfect -
 reality/real -
 fact -
(You can just type or past them to the above, if you like). Short and simple hopefully.

I told you I'm not going to define all the words I use. You won't even define one word, "God", the point of the whole discussion. I don't think you really need all those words explained.