(May 30, 2018 at 12:29 pm)Ybe Wrote: There are many proofs and evidences given for G. Example of just one. Proof.
(https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gödel%27s_...ical_proof)
From the wikipedia article:
Quote:First, Gödel axiomatizes the notion of a "positive property":[note 2] for each property φ, either φ or its negation ¬φ must be positive, but not both (axiom 2). If a positive property φ implies a property ψ in each possible world, then ψ is positive, too (axiom 1). Gödel then argues that each positive property is "possibly exemplified", i.e. applies at least to some object in some world (theorem 1). Defining an object to be Godlike if it has all positive properties (definition 1), and requiring that property to be positive itself (axiom 3),[note 3] Gödel shows that in some possible world a Godlike object exists (theorem 2), called "God" in the following.[note 4] Gödel proceeds to prove that a Godlike object exists in every possible world.
There is no such thing as an objectively "positive" property. Godel has erred. And his proof fails because his premising the existence of "positive" properties is unsound.