RE: Ontological Disproof of God
August 31, 2018 at 8:48 am
(This post was last modified: August 31, 2018 at 9:50 am by negatio.)
(August 31, 2018 at 7:07 am)Abaddon_ire Wrote:(August 31, 2018 at 3:03 am)robvalue Wrote: @neg: By "it", I meant Yahweh. Yahweh is too stupid to be a deity, as written in the bible, or is playing dumb.
My writing is cryptic? How so?
Given the thread, it is a rather odd accusation to make.
Negatio was merely making a one word observation, then, Abaddon leaped to ''accusation" ?! I am not making, and will not make, in future, any sort of ascription of fault to Robvalue, regarding my impression of the mysterious, spiraling, juxtaposition of terms Rob employs, No; Rob's sentences are cryptic, is that a fault ?, no, its a poetry, almost, distantly, a Gene Genet-like tempo, cast in a brightly comic-book coloration, I, for some reason, imagine colorful personages dancing about, when I read Robvalue...Negatio. P.S.. I am down to maybe an hour, an hour and a half of fuel whereby to generate electricity; my friend who always helps me haul fuel with his truck, had a shoulder operation yesterday, and is in agonizing pain; I am attempting to make other arrangements; so, if I disappear for some period, you now know the reason; I had to say so, because when if the computer had just gone dead, and, I was offline for a time, you guys would be puzzled...
(August 30, 2018 at 12:54 pm)robvalue Wrote: I'm not sure how you go about tackling characters in books of fiction. Are we saying that Yahweh, if he was real and as described, wouldn't be a deity? Or that within the fictional universe of the book, he isn't a deity? (Or maybe that the fictional world as described can't correlate with ours?)
He appears to be higher on the hierarchy than us in either case, just by being more powerful, even if he's a total dimwit. And he supposedly made man, in both cases.
(Or maybe that the fictional world as described can't correlate with ours?)
Yes, precisely, the world of Yahweh, whether it was a fiction, or a real historical state of affairs where Moses actually had the stone tablets and everything, does not totally matter, but, whatever it was, real, or fictional, I am indeed saying that that Yahweh-Christ world fails, in a cardinal consideration, to correlate with the way our existence upon the face of this earth actually transpires in regard to how we humans originate and upsurge our acts ! Yes, precisely, absolutely, Robvalue ! Wow, yes ! Negatio.
