(November 7, 2018 at 11:26 pm)Whateverist Wrote:(November 7, 2018 at 9:08 pm)polymath257 Wrote: An old problem of Hipparchus.
Thanks for the Hipparchus reference. I didn't know that and will have to look into who that was. I don't recall where I encountered it but for whatever reason I woke up too early this morning thinking about it and had to recreate it.
I love the elegance of the solution though and how unlikely it seems when you consider the shape whose area we must find in itself. Very satisfying I think.
There is a generalization due to al-Haytham. Take a large half-circle with diameter AB. Inscribe a triangle ABC where C is on the half-circle. Now, draw two half circles with diameters AC and BC outside of the triangle.
The question concerns the area outside the original circle and inside the two smaller circles.
The Hipparchus figure is where the point C is on a perpendicular bisector of AB.