(November 13, 2019 at 6:24 pm)Gae Bolga Wrote: Then, in a possible world, it is necessarily true that the future cannot be known, therefore it is true in all possible worlds that the future cannot be known.
I'm not sure I follow. Maybe you're defining possible world differently than what I'm used to reading. But the way I see it, in a possible world, the future can be known by an all-knowing being but it cannot be changed.
I agree a lot of it is word game, and I would personally just challenge the logically-oriented theist to logically establish free will instead of assuming it is possible at the start to try to see if it's compatible with another notion that I'm also not quite sure is logical (omniscience).
