Roger Penrose is a hack

[brokenreflector]

Quite simply we probably wouldn't watch the video unless you pointed out a good reason to and then we would most likely just talk about whatever point you brought up.

So, to your point about there being three aspects I would say, that abstract is neither mind, nor physical but I wouldn't equate it with astral or supernatural.

You didn't watch the video, did you?

It's like you guys are allergic to learning.

It's not my point. It's Roger Penrose's point.

If there are three aspects: physical, mental, and abstract, then the mental and abstract would be by definition SUPER-natural or transcendental in the sense that they're not of physical reality. Now go watch the video.