The Watchmaker: my fav argument

[Pat Mustard]

It does, idiot.  If a god creates imperfect beings, that shows that it too is imperfect.  And while evolution doesn't disprove a generic god* it does show that such a being is not necessary for us to exist.

*It does disprove the abrahamic god, because it shows that the claimse made about said god are false.

It only follows if creating imperfect beings is not the right thing to do.  It also ignores that there may be multiple interests at stake which conflict.  Flawed but free beings may be preferable to perfect but not free ones.

But its not about what is preferrable but about what's perfect. A perfect being cannot create imperfect things.

A good illustration of that idea is Olaf Stapledon's Star Maker.