(March 29, 2021 at 3:05 pm)HappySkeptic Wrote: You seem to be trying to make the claim that if a theory makes a wrong prediction, the choice whether to throw out the theory completely, or whether to simply change it is arbitrary. Therefore there is no way to scientifically choose one over the other.
Therefore ID is just as good as modifications to modern evolutionary theory?
I agree that the choice to modify or replace a theory is rather subjective. And ID can certainly be revised as often as it needs. But I've mostly been responding to questions about evolution; I'm not making arguments about ID here.