(June 27, 2009 at 3:18 pm)fr0d0 Wrote: There is evidence for God, it just can't be provable. Everything in the universe is proof of God's existence. Or not. Depending on your POV.
Once again--you've done this several times now--you've gone from "No evidence" to "no provable evidence" (or "no empirical evidence" as you've said before too!)...
If 'everything in the universe' is 'proof of God's existence' but it 'depends on your point of view', then if it depends on your point of view, it's not objective...there's no substance there and it's not evidence of any shape or form. Whether provable or not...otherwise you might as well say that anything is evidence for anything else ...it just depends on your POV!! It's a completely meaningless statement.
Evidence has to be objective whether provable...or not - otherwise it's in no way evidence because it can apply to anything and everything which IOW equates to it applying to NOTHING. It's not evidence by that definition at all....it's just subjective nonsense..."Well it's evidence to me...it's not provable evidence...but it's evidence to me" - that's just entirely nonsensical, by definition that's not evidence. It can't 'depend on your point of view' and be subjective like that or it's not evidence of any shape or form.
EvF
