(March 22, 2023 at 12:14 pm)The Grand Nudger Wrote: Just to be clear, you're asking me... if...had you done The Wrong Thing, wouldn't it still be less wrong than other papers that didn't even attempt to do The Wrong Thing?
I mean, sure, a weak p-value can be alarming that the conclusion is wrong. But isn't a paper that doesn't even attempt to calculate a p-value way more alarming in that regard than a paper that has a weak p-value?