My Revelation

[Bucky Ball]

Lec

Sorry. I can't accept that. I always wanted to be a great baseball player and I have played baseball. I could believe all I want, feel like a great player and identify as one. It would be no help to me to have people pretend to agree with me. By the way, what makes a great player?  Is it what I think it is or what it really is. Can I hit, field, steal, pitch, etc. I think a great player strikes out all the time, misses fly balls, is slow on the base pads, etc.  Am I correct?

We don't care if you accept it. You wanting to be a great baseball player has nothing to do with gender identities as this isn't a person who wants to be the opposite gender they already are it. For Trans people respect and acknowledgement does help and has helped or this statement is simply false. Also what makes a great baseball player is totally subjective and could non physical i might add (Good sportsmanship or having Team Spirit etc)

 No he's not correct. But his example (as you point out) has a name. Fallacy of the false analogy.