@the grand nudge
It seems a disagreement over terms rather than substance, then. Does God or morality exist in some external sense outside of the minds, feelings and opinions of agents in the same way rocks and cats do? No. Do prople have strong sensations and feelings which lead them believe they do? Yes. Do actions have physical consequences? Yes. Do these consequences have a property susceptible to the scientific method called badness? No.
It seems a disagreement over terms rather than substance, then. Does God or morality exist in some external sense outside of the minds, feelings and opinions of agents in the same way rocks and cats do? No. Do prople have strong sensations and feelings which lead them believe they do? Yes. Do actions have physical consequences? Yes. Do these consequences have a property susceptible to the scientific method called badness? No.