Perhaps it would help if you told us what exactly your premises and what your conclusions are. For example ...
Kindly do the same for the argument you are asking us to refute.
(December 19, 2011 at 1:43 pm)amkerman Wrote: premis 1: all men are mortal
premis 2: socrates is a man
conclusion (based on premis 1 and premis 2): therefore socrates is mortal
Kindly do the same for the argument you are asking us to refute.