Hello soulcalm17

[soulcalm17]

God wants people to being true happy in their life, so that He gave us the revelation that's including story in it.

He cares about humans?

My reply:
Yes, of course he is. He has a plan. And he already decided that good people will go to jannah (paradise), while the bad people will go to hell.

If He didn’t care, he wouldn’t send the revelation that remind human to his decision. He will ignore it but still make the decision in afterlife that bad people go to hell. It would be not fair. That’s why He always show the right path to every person so that each person would not complain to Him in afterlife, like saying: why did you not give knowledge/enlightment about this before, so that I become true and good believer?
This reminding, like I remind you today, is the evidence that He is fair and actually want people to go to the paradise.

---

The writing/speech style

I think you are talking about textual analysis. This is something that was used to figure out if different people wrote the Bible and how many people. It isn’t something that I am familiar with.
Mormons have recently invested a lot into this. There are researchers at Brigham Young University who work on this sort of thing. When I say recently, I mean around 2010 and to this date.
I imagine all the experts have concluded that Joseph Smith did not write the Book of Mormon. By experts, I mean that they have a diploma and they are also mormons.


My Reply:
I looking at a glance to the book of Mormon. Easily concluded it was man made. Too many subject of “I” who is clear depicting the POV of that book, which is testimony of human.

Indeed, quite many religions use that kind of style. The writing of followers/disciples about religion that their accept from the Prophet, but with their thought also. That is the first problem generating deviation possibilities of religions. That case never happened in Islam. Because we are prohibited to adding our thoughts to the subject of revelations. We just wrote words by words the revelation coming from Prophet.

Qur’an’s quote:
…Who does more wrong than those who fabricate lies against Allah to mislead others without any knowledge? Surely Allah does not guide the wrongdoing people. (Al An’am 6:144)
Hadith’s quote:
…Whoever lies in my name deliberately, let his seat be prepared in hell… (Musnad Ahmad: 11711)

I’m not seeing anything special in those lines.
Which one of those is said by the jewish god and how do you know?

My Reply:
The first clearly come from other than Muhammad peace be upon him entity, which has no subject like “I”, or “my”. And in Quran, never the story events of Muhammad ﷺ mentioned by first subject like “I” or “my” that referring to Muhammad ﷺ.

The second one “my” is from Muhammad ﷺ. Clearly “my” is from the POV of human, which is Muhammad himself ﷺ.

From the example, we know that the Quran style is more complex, like a poem, but with deep meaning, than one in the hadith.

Your claim seems to be that humans are incapable of this: writing a poem, giving a meaning to text.
Yes, it is possible for a human to write 2 pieces of text: one piece contains a poem and the other does not.
This isn’t something that is out of the bounds of possibility.

My Reply:
So you still considered it as possibility. But the fact was abundant in history. That many words of Muhammad peace be upon him in hadists is very different with the Quran. Arabs people when facing two style of writing directly know that one is Muhammad’s direct speech while the other is divinity’s speech spoken by human.

We have possibilities. But we need observation to test the possibilities. Your possibility simply didn’t match with the fact that Muhammad is not a poet before. He never made poem by himself. And his style of words is very different with Quran.

---