Hello soulcalm17

[soulcalm17]

Surah At Tawba 9:49
There are some of them who say, “Exempt me and do not expose me to temptation.”1 They have already fallen into temptation. And Hell will surely engulf the disbelievers. If a blessing befalls you ˹O Prophet˺, they grieve, but if a disaster befalls you, they say, “We took our precaution in advance,” and turn away, rejoicing. Say, “Nothing will ever befall us except what Allah has destined for us. He is our Protector.” So in Allah let the believers put their trust.

And the text continues. It essentially considers the muslims who wanted to stay behind at the camp as disbelievers, as fuckers, as fags, as bags of shit. They deserve hell.
It also says that if Mohamed fails to gain victory, these guys would say “Glad I didn’t go. Glad I’m safe.”

The lines above might be documenting actual events and the lines are obviously written after these events.
It might be that Mohamed won that war. i don’t know.
It looks like Mohamed is pissed off that some able body men decided to not risk their lives.

My Reply:

Verse 49 also explains the condition of hypocrites. The hypocrites mentioned, who did not take part in the war, deserved punishment. Because they weaken the Muslims. And the prophet Muhammad did win in that war. Win without spending any energy in battle. Because the Roman army was afraid and did not dare to face the Muslim troops. And the Muslim troops went home because they had no one to fight.
 
However, no. This verse did not come down after the war ended. This verse came down when Muhammad invited people to join the war. The verse states that the hypocrites, when the Muslim troops win in the war, they would be resentful (because they would not had spoil of war). However, if the Muslims lose the war, they will rejoice and say things like: I told you not to join the war. That is the trait of cowardice revealed by Allah in the Quran. And so that it becomes a lesson for Muslims not to follow their path.
Continue here:

---

At Tahrim 66:1
O Prophet! Why do you prohibit yourself from what Allah has made lawful to you, seeking to please your wives? And Allah is All-Forgiving, Most Merciful.
The question is still: Why would he blame himslef in front of his companion?

I don’t know Mohamed personally and I don’t know his family members or any of his friends, so I can’t know definitely what happened a very long time ago.
Maybe he was unhappy with something that he did. He felt like confessing. He felt the need for help from the jewish god.
Maybe he wants to serve as a model, as a way to live for his followers.
Yes, sometimes guys like Mohamed server as teachers. They tell us directly how to live or gives examples from their lives.

My Reply:

It should be emphasized in this verse that Allah has previously explained what foods and drinks which are halal (permitted) to eat, and which are haram (prohibited) to consume. This verse was revealed in connection with an event experienced by the Prophet Muhammad Shallallahu Alaihi Wasallam. At that time the Prophet was at the house of his wife, Saudah and drink honey.
This incident seems to be the cause of jealousy of the prophet's other wives, named Aisyah and Hafsah. When the Prophet Muhammad went to Aisyah's house, Aisyah suddenly said that the Prophet's mouth smelled bad. Likewise, when the Prophet went to Hafsah's house. Hafsah said that the Prophet's mouth smelled bad.
The Prophet Muhammad, who heard the confessions of his two wives, then concluded that it was because he drank honey while at Sauda's house. On that basis, in order to please his two wives, the Messenger of Allah made honey forbidden to him forever.
This is a mistake. So, God sent down this At Tahrim letter to warn the Prophet that what he was doing was wrong. Honey is halal for humans. And no one has the right to forbid it, except God himself. God also told the Prophet to withdraw his words.
What is underlined in the revelation of this verse is that it is impossible for the Prophet to cancel his own words if he did not receive a revelation from God. Logically, he must have kept his words and not changed them to please his wife.

END OF BLOCK OF TEXT


START OF BLOCK OF TEXT

Surah Ar Ruum 30:2-4
The Romans have been defeated in a nearby land.1 Yet following their defeat, they will triumph within three to nine years.1 The ˹whole˺ matter rests with Allah before and after ˹victory˺. And on that day the believers will rejoice at the victory willed by Allah. He gives victory to whoever He wills. For He is the Almighty, Most Merciful.

So, the prophecy is that in 3 to 9 years, the Romans will win.
Sorry, I have no idea what this is about. Why does it say 3 to 9? Why can’t it give a specific time? What year is it. Where? With who are they at war? At what date and time was Surah Ar Ruum 30:2-4 written?


My Reply:
First of all, don't get wrong. The Al-Quran was revealed by the Angel Gabriel to the Prophet Muhammad, then the Prophet Muhammad memorized it. Then the Prophet Muhammad spoke this to his followers. Then his followers memorized it. Indeed, when the Prophet Muhammad lived, there was no canonical Al-Quran written in full, because at that time, companions already memorize all the revelations given. So what you know from history is that the Quran was only collected during Uthman's caliphate, which was true. But that is only in written form. As for the oral tradition, the Quran already exists and has not changed even when it was written down during the time of Caliph Uthman. Thus, the content, word for word, was revealed before they were collected in a book called a mushaf.

As for the words three to nine years, the Arabic language actually says that to refer to the term several years (فِي بِضْعِ سِنِينَ "fii bid'i siniin"). This letter first came down in 615 AD, just when Roman was defeated. So the prediction was correct.

In those days the Byzantine occupied territories adjacent to Arabia were Jordan, Syria and Palestine, and in these territories the Romans were completely overpowered by the Persians in 615 A.D. And proved that later in 624 A.D, The Romans defeating Persians by destroyed Clorumia, the birthplace of Zoroaster, and ravaged the principal fire temple of Persian.

It isn’t clear in which days it is talking about. The text is not dated.
No mention of countries is made. No mention of cities is made. No mention of commanders, generals, leaders.
No mention of who the enemy is.
Besides, 615 and 624 are inferior numbers to 632, which is when Mohamed was dead and it is after that that some guys wrote the Koran. So we don’t know if previous to 615, Mohamed said those lines.

Surah Al Fath, 48:27
“Indeed, Allah will fulfil His Messenger’s vision in all truth: Allah willing, you will surely enter the Sacred Mosque, in security—some with heads shaved and others with hair shortened—without fear. He knew what you did not know, so He first granted you the triumph at hand”.

Those lines were written after 632, which is when Mohamed was dead and it is after that that some guys wrote the Koran.
In other words, they went into some sacred church, which I don’t know which one they are talking about. There was only 1 sacred church in Saudi Arabia?
You said that in 630, Mohamed and friends came to Mecca and went into some sacred church.
The text does not state 630 and it does not state who will enter the sacred church. In other words, if they had failed to enter in 630, there is no expiration date. Muslims could have succeeded in entering he sacred church in the year 2010 and you would say that the prophecy has been fulfilled.
It is similar in the case of Israel. The claim is that it was prophecized that jews would get back Israel and they did in 1948.

How about if Mohamed predicts in 630 that in the 19 th century, an X number of elements would be discovered and that a certain person, I guess Mendelev would work on the periodic table of elements?
How about if Mohamed predicts in 630 that a very powerful weapon, called a nuclear weapon would be developed during the 193x?
It need not be something of a scientific nature. Mohamed could have drawn a map of New York, showed all the street names, all the bridges with names, a list of mayors.
Now that would be impressive.

My Reply:

Again, you conclude wrongly. The verse above was first revealed in 615 AD. As for the matter of the Quran being written after the Prophet Muhammad, it has nothing to do with this incident. Remember, the Quran after the death of the Prophet was only written. As for orally, the Quran has been spread and memorized by many companions before. And there was not even slight change between the Al-Quran delivered orally and the writing written in the Al-Quran mushaf.
 
As for the question of why the name of the country does not appear, the names of generals and leaders. So I can say here that the Quran is not a historical notebook written scientifically. No, that's not why the Quran was revealed. He was revealed to give wisdom and moral lessons to humans. Occasionally he reveals historical facts, but for humans to reflect on the lessons contained therein.

---