Hello soulcalm17

[Belacqua]

Rarely.

So you're only in the small town for one night, and you want to eat at the best restaurant.

Is it rational to conclude that the subjective opinion of the 99% is good evidence that the restaurant is in fact the best one?

Or is it rational to conclude that another restaurant, picked at random, has an equally good chance of being the best one? 

If you think that the opinion of the 99% is more likely to be correct, then their subjective opinion counts as evidence, which it is rational to listen to.