(January 5, 2013 at 3:54 pm)Shell B Wrote: Wow. That made no sense at all. I don't think words work the way you think they do.
You talking to me or the theist?
If you are talking to me.
To me it does not matter what example you want to use. Once you start setting parameters on the claim "all powerful" you have defeted the concept.
"all" in "all powerful" means can do anything and everything. That includes being illogical. I like my explinations to reality to be logical not illogical.
It still boils down to the theist's starting point being "he can do what he wants" which allows them to move the goal posts to avoid inconsistancies in logic.
